OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

Name: OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx
Price: 11.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 3.6 (122 reviews)

Curated from 122 real Reddit conversations

Refreshed on: March 25, 2025

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

Brand: OPI

Price: $11

Snoop Score:

3.6

Sentiment

4.5

Popularity

1.6

Technical

4.4

Buy on Amazon for $11 See All Nail Polish Reviews

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Snoop's Take

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx is a vegan, opaque, dark black crème nail polish designed to deliver salon-quality coverage and chip-resistant durability. It dries quickly for a high-shine finish and boasts a specially designed brush for smooth and even application. Consumer sentiment is as polarized as it is passionate; many users exclaim, 'OPI is my go to. I use nothing else,' praising its bold color payoff and rich formula, while others grumble about issues like inconsistent drying and a gloopy texture. Some appreciate the thick, luxurious feel for an even coat, yet conflicting experiences with formula consistency have sparked heated debates among enthusiasts. Ultimately, if you prioritize a statement-making color above flawless performance, this nail lacquer holds its own in the competitive beauty market. However, caution is advised for those who demand consistent, professional-grade results—its merits and drawbacks make it a product best suited for loyal OPI fans who can overlook minor technical imperfections.

Not for you? Check out our other rated Nail Polish

OPI is my go to. I use nothing else.
Positive Feedback

My nails are dry, but if I put on socks or do too much around the house, the polish will- for sure- get messed up.
Negative Feedback

3.6

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

Buy on Amazon for $11

DIY Manicures

3 / 10

Special Occasion Styling

4 / 10

Professional Salon Use

10 / 10

Gift and Trend Setting

4 / 10

See how this compares to all Nail Polish

What it does well!

Key strengths users can’t stop talking about.

Good color options

“OPI is my go to. I use nothing else.”➕

“Same. I buy every collection I can.”➕

“OPI is gloopy... just me? I bought Bubble Bath a few months back, couldn't get it to dry down, just ”➕

“I agree! I hate OPIs formula, but I like their colors :(”➕

Generally liked by long-time users

“I love OPI. That's out of the 100+ I've tried.”➕

High-quality brush for application

“One thing I always loved about OPI was the brush.”➕

Good quality polish with decent lasting ability

“OPI is a good brand though. Their polish is nice and lasts about a week.”➕

“Overall, I'd say they're pretty good, especially their lacquer colors.”➕

Good application with thick and viscous formula

“I quickly learned that OPI was pretty dope cause the polish was super thick and like viscous, so you could get a perfectly distributed coat in 2 movements.”➕

“Como SE Lama has been my literal favourite polish this autumn and I've had it on multiple times and the formula is so amazing to work with.”➕

Consistently good experience with some shades

“Overall I think OPI is consistently good.”➕

Smooth application with user-friendly brush

“OPI applies more smoothly than cheaper polishes, and the brush is more user-friendly.”➕

Good performance with regular lacquer

“I’ve never had issues with it!”➕

“regular lacquer seems to do fine.”➕

Long-lasting wear reported by users

“my manicure lasts 10 days, pedicure 3 weeks.”➕

Quick drying time reported by users

“I even usually do three coats of Princesses rule when I wear that shade and it still dries quickly.”➕

Where it needs some work!

Areas to watch—feedback on possible improvements.

Polish does not dry completely

“My nails are dry, but if I put on socks or do too much around the house, the polish will- for sure- get messed up.”➕

“I've found that my nail polish just does not dry 100% until the next day.”➕

“OPI never works well for me either. It never dries and stays gummy.”➕

“OPI is a polish I’ve never had any problems with and I have a lot of it.”➕

Inconsistent formula quality

“OPI is consistently one of the best, most buttery and self levelling formulas for me.”➕

“It really depends on the colour you get.”➕

“I've noticed the ones I've bought at Marshalls or TJ Maxx have the most terrible textures.”➕

“the goopiest application of any bottle I have experienced.”➕

Thick and streaky application

“Same. Or it's streaky, or thick, or bubbles, despite every trick in the book.”➕

“I used to hate opi. Some of the formulas are bad but I found once I changed the brushes out for the kbshimmer brushes, that helped quite a bit.”➕

Quality has declined over time

“I swear their polish used to be really good and last for a while but I now it chips within the next two days!!!”➕

“I don’t know that their quality is going down as much as folks are realizing it was never there to begin with.”➕

“I do feel like their price stayed stable while the quality decreased, but that’s true of most mainstream brands at that price point the last few years.”➕

Inconsistent color collections

“The last several collections have felt as if they're just throwing darts at a color wheel and calling it done.”➕

Inconsistent wear time, chips within a few days

“The longest I've ever gotten was about 10 days with minor wear and no big chips.”➕

Inconsistent formula quality across different shades

“OPI is the most over hyped and inconsistent imo.”➕

Streaky application reported for some colors

“did not like them due to being streaky, gloopy, and needing many coats to be opaque.”➕

Inconsistent color quality leading to uneven application

“This happens every time with the lighter colors, funny bunny, alpine snow, & any nudes.”➕

“The finish they have is so weird.”➕

“I haven’t really had good experiences with opi gel.”➕

“I’ve always felt like OPI gel colors seem 'watered down.'”➕

Gloopy and thick application issues

“I don't think so. It was still pretty sheer and I waited a long time between coats, too.”➕

Inconsistent color quality

“Their colors are kind of hit and miss.”➕

Average performance noted by some users

“I've always found them shockingly average.”➕

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Product Name	Price	Score	See Details	Buy Now
Sally Hansen Insta-Dri® Taupe Priority	$5	7.3	Details	Buy
modelones Nail Polish Set 12 Colors Nude Pink Quick Dry Mini Nail Lacquer Kit	$8	6.5	Details	Buy
AZUREBEAUTY Vegan Glitter Pearl Nail Polish	$6	6.3	Details	Buy
modelones Nail Polish Set 6 Colors Pink Collection Red Cat Eye Nail Polish Set	$9	5.7	Details	Buy
essie Salon-Quality Nail Polish, Sugar Daddy	$9	5.5	Details	Buy
wet n wild Wild Shine Nail Polish Tickled Pink	$1	5.2	Details	Buy
Glamonade Blooming Gel Nail Polish	$10	5.2	Details	Buy
OPI Nail Lacquer Big Apple Red	$11	5.1	Details	Buy
OPI Nail Lacquer Incognito Mode	$8	5.1	Details	Buy
L.A. COLORS Color Craze Nail Polish, Glitter Bomb CNP543	$0	4.9	Details	Buy
SAVILAND Glows in The Dark Gel Nail Polish Set	$19	4.5	Details	Buy
OPI Nail Lacquer Funny Bunny	$11	4.4	Details	Buy
OPI Nail Lacquer Put it in Neutral	$11	4.1	Details	Buy
Born Pretty 6 Colors Jelly Gel Nail Polish Set	$16	3.8	Details	Buy
OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx	$11	3.6	Details	Buy
OPI RapiDry Fuego On-the-Go	$9	3.2	Details	Buy
JLCYJEYGI 6ml Nail Polish Plating Silver Paste Color	$3	2.0	Details	Buy

Core Power Plays

The specs and strengths that make it shine.

Interest in color availability

“It's the perfect in-between of orange, red, coral and pops on my skin tone.”➕

“IMO its a really orangey red.”➕

“It looks like polish pick still has it.”➕

“What OPI color could this be?”➕

Discussion on differences between OPI systems

“I wore my infinite shine ('Sky True to Yourself' shade to anyone interested) and it lasted for a week without chipping.”➕

Discussion on nail polish and self-expression

“So fuck it. I feel pretty.”➕

“Best thing you can do is maintain that spirit.”➕

“It's fuckin nice to feel pretty.”➕

“The best time to go is when they're mostly empty and the nail techs are bored.”➕

Experiences with manicures and pedicures among men

“He loved the experience, and how nice his nails looked!”➕

“If he can overcome any self-doubt, anyone can.”➕

“He was so resistant! Lol. But after, he loved the pampering.”➕

“Those huge football players getting pedicures and chatting with their buddies is just so darn wholesome.”➕

Community for men painting nails

“OPI Black Onyx Londontown kur ridge filler base coat, OPI black onyx for the color, and Seche Vite top coat.”➕

“Thank you for posting to r/malepolish, the subreddit for men (and others) of all ages who paint our nails.”➕

Inquiry about brush types on different OPI polishes

“Mine has a skinny brush.”➕

“it should be a green label with a wide brush.”➕

Admiration for natural nails

“Omg, they are absolutely perfect.”➕

Hidden Hero Hacks

Unexpected tricks and side‑door uses you’ll love.

Discussion on using thinner to improve formula

“Thinner fixes it right up, though!”➕

Preference for Seche Vite top coat

“it's super shinny.”➕

“I tend to stick to the dry fast.”➕

Discussion on application techniques affecting drying

“Would literally take 12-24 hours for them to dry, even with quick-dry drops.”➕

Interest in the OPI dip system

“I think Im addicted now.”➕

“Isn’t OPI dip the best 😍”➕

“Is that right?”➕

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

What to check before you click ‘Add to Cart.’

Interest in quick dry solutions

“Any decent quick dry top coat will be dry to the touch well within thirty minutes.”➕

“Try the Sally Hansen insta dri. Worked well for me.”➕

Discussion on top coat vs. color layer

“Actual top coat, not a third layer of polish.”➕

Concerns about purchasing from discount stores

“i wouldn’t judge it solely based on a polish from Marshalls”➕

Discussion about nail polish longevity expectations

“I have seen a couple posts about OPI, but a lot of people were mostly talking about the colors of OPI that they didn't like.”➕

“I honestly don’t think any regular nail polish will last two weeks.”➕

Discussion on overpriced designer nail polishes

“A Gucci polish isn’t going to make a difference. The high price for designer polishes doesn’t mean that they will be better in any way.”➕

“Designer pricing is all about what the target market will bear. Cool bottles though!”➕

Comparison to other non-designer brands

“Don’t buy polishes from expensive designer clothes brands.”➕

Preference for other brands like Luxa over OPI

“I prefer luxa but my clients always go for opi.”➕

Discussion on quality differences between expensive and cheap polishes

“Is it worth buying O.P.I etc more expensive nailpolishes and why?”➕

“I'm always pleasantly surprised by the quality of Catrice polishes!”➕

“From some polishes it's impossible to tell whether they're expensive or cheap.”➕

Interest in nail polish longevity

“How many days of wear can I expect from both?”➕

Interest in affordable nail polish options at discount stores

“just got these 3 for less than the price of one on OPI’s website :-)”➕

“They have so many fun options and they’re half the price of the nails at CVS”➕

“$5-8 a set. That's a steal!!”➕

“that's even cheaper than Walmart prices.”➕

Mention of other brands preferred by users

“ILNP is my favorite. It’s a thinner polish and I haven’t had any problems other than certain ones.”➕

Interest in collecting older OPI black labels

“Does anyone else collect OPI Black Labels? I know there’s a few of us here.”➕

“Beautiful color! I collect older OPIs, but really old black labels are hard to find here in Europe.”➕

Discussion about differences in OPI bottle designs over time

“the font for OPI at the top is totally different on modern bottles.”➕

Cautionary Callouts

Know the pitfalls before they catch you off guard.

Personal experiences with quality of various brands

“if I use the 'right' base and top coat, you can't even tell they're old and they last a whole week.”➕

“It all boils down to trial and error.”➕

Discussion on mixing brands of nail polish

“Should you generally stick to the same brand for base, polish, and top coat? I keep hearing something like the brands are chemically engineered to make all the products work best together but I’m not sure if that’s legit or just marketing.”➕

“The 'systems' are mostly marketing. I've never had an issue mixing multiple brands together.”➕

“There is no reason why different brands of lacquer shouldn't be used together.”➕

“If you see di-HEMA Trimethylhexyl Dicarbamate (di-HEMA TMHDC) in the polish ingredients you need to use the matching top coat.”➕

Cultural perceptions of nail polish on men

“Dude is awesome, plain and simple.”➕

“Feel pretty fam, you deserve it.”➕

Discussion on nail health and fragility

“I cannot believe these are my grown nails, they feel so strong and indestructible.”➕

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

Curated from 122 real Reddit conversations

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

Snoop's Take

OPI Nail Lacquer Black Onyx

DIY Manicures

Special Occasion Styling

Professional Salon Use

Gift and Trend Setting

What it does well!

Where it needs some work!

Compare On All Talked About Dimensions

Core Power Plays

Hidden Hero Hacks

Buyer’s Cheat Sheet

Cautionary Callouts

You May Also Like

Explore more Categories